12 Fall themed Cozy Mysteries to Read Right Now

If you’re like me, when autumn comes, you start wanting those cozy, feel-good vibes that only a great cozy mystery can bring. Even though I am a huge fan of psychological thrillers, there’s something about the autumn nights that makes me reach for a cozy mystery. I love how these books have just the right mix of suspense, fun characters, small towns, and a bit of humor—without being too serious.

What’s great about cozy mysteries is how comforting they are, even when there’s a mystery to solve. They’re perfect for relaxing after a long day or getting lost in on a quiet weekend. So, if you’re looking for some cozy mysteries to add to your fall reading here are some of my top picks. These are cozy mystery books are perfect to add to your October reading list along with some Halloween romances.

Best Cozy Mysteries to Curl Up With in 2024

Between a Flock and a Hard Place by Donna Andrews

Meg Langslow returns in another quirky mystery filled with eccentric neighbors and even more eccentric animals. When the Smetkamps’ home makeover is interrupted by a flock of territorial turkeys, Meg is just trying to keep the peace. But when Mrs. Smetkamp is found dead in her backyard, and it looks like someone tried to pin the crime on one of the turkeys, Meg and the local authorities aren’t fooled. With a mix of humor and suspense, this latest installment in the Meg Langslow series will have you laughing and sleuthing along with the flock.

BUY NOW ON AMAZON  | LISTEN FREE ON AUDIBLE

Town in a Pumpkin Bash by B.B. Haywood

In the charming village of Cape Willington, Maine, Halloween preparations are in full swing for the annual Pumpkin Bash. Candy Holliday is excited to run the haunted hayride this year, but things take a dark turn when she stumbles upon a real dead body among the fake tombstones. Candy’s attention to detail might just help her uncover the secrets buried deep in this seaside town. This cozy mystery with feel-good fall setting will leave you eager for the next chapter—plus, it includes some delicious recipes to try at home!

BUY NOW ON AMAZON  | LISTEN FREE ON AUDIBLE | READ with Kindle Unlimited

Mischief Nights are Murder by Libby Klein

As Halloween approaches, Poppy McAllister’s B&B is reluctantly dragged into a haunted dinner tour. Between her quirky guests—like a pet psychic and a tabloid reporter—things were already chaotic. But when one of them ends up dead, face-first in a plate of tiramisu, Poppy has more than mischievous pranks to worry about. With a haunted reputation hanging over her B&B and a murder mystery to solve, this book is packed with plenty of humor, lovable characters, and spooky thrills.

BUY NOW ON AMAZON  | LISTEN FREE ON AUDIBLE | READ with Kindle Unlimited

The Ghost of Lilly Pilly Creek by Abbie L. Martin

Set in the serene Adelaide Hills of South Australia, Jones returns to her hometown after the tragic death of her sister, Autumn. But when Autumn’s ghost appears, Jones is thrown into a race against time to uncover the truth behind her sister’s death. As they reopen their family’s bookshop and unravel the mystery together, Jones discovers that the past is full of secrets—and danger. With a mix of the supernatural and a tight-knit community, this cozy mystery will keep you captivated until the last page.

BUY NOW ON AMAZON  | LISTEN FREE ON AUDIBLE

Homicide and Honeycrisps by Summer Prescott

Mackenzie Appleton loves running her family’s apple farm, but things take a sinister turn when a body is found in their corn maze. As if that wasn’t enough, one of her trusted employees is a suspect. Determined to protect her farm and her people, Mac sets out to solve the mystery, but danger lurks around every corner. This sweet mini-mystery is packed with heartwarming moments, and it even includes a recipe to enjoy while you try to solve the case alongside Mac.

BUY NOW ON AMAZON  | LISTEN FREE ON AUDIBLE | READ with Kindle Unlimited

Death Over Easy by Maddie Day

Robbie Jordan is gearing up for a busy weekend as her café hosts guests for a local bluegrass festival. But when one of the musicians is found strangled with a banjo string, the festival takes a dark turn. As all eyes fall on the remaining banjo players, Robbie finds herself wrapped up in another murder investigation. With the festival in full swing and a new bed and breakfast to run, Robbie must work quickly to uncover the truth before the killer strikes again.

BUY NOW ON AMAZON  | LISTEN FREE ON AUDIBLE | READ with Kindle Unlimited

Sinfully Delicious by Amanda M. Lee

Stormy Morgan thought life couldn’t get worse after her failed attempt at writing the great American novel, but tripping over a dead body changes everything. Now back in her hometown of Shadow Hills, Michigan, Stormy finds herself thrust into a murder investigation alongside her old high school flame, Hunter Ryan. With a possible ghostly twist and plenty of small-town secrets, this is one murder mystery where the dead aren’t the only ones with something to hide.

BUY NOW ON AMAZON  | LISTEN FREE ON AUDIBLE | READ with Kindle Unlimited

The Murders in Great Diddling by Katarina Bivald

Author Berit Gardner finds herself in the middle of a real-life mystery when an explosion rocks the quiet village of Great Diddling. The locals band together to start a book and murder festival to attract tourists, but as Berit soon discovers, there are plenty of secrets hidden in this sleepy village. With quirky characters and a plot that celebrates the magic of storytelling, this cozy mystery is as charming as it is puzzling.

BUY NOW ON AMAZON  | LISTEN FREE ON AUDIBLE

Tracking Tilly by Janice Thompson

When RaeLyn Hadley’s family antique business faces hard times, she knows buying back her grandfather’s old red truck, Tilly, could be the key to turning things around. But when Tilly is stolen after the auction, RaeLyn steps into the role of amateur sleuth to track down the culprit. With small-town charm and plenty of family dynamics, this mystery is filled with nostalgia and heart as RaeLyn tries to solve the case and save her family’s new venture.

BUY NOW ON AMAZON  | LISTEN FREE ON AUDIBLE

Haunted to Death by Frank Anthony Polito

Renovating a haunted house isn’t exactly what home renovation hosts Peter Penwell and JP Broadway had in mind for their hit reality show. As they work on restoring Woods Hall, strange things start to happen—sightings of a ghost, mysterious injuries, and even sabotage. But when they uncover a decades-old murder mystery, the stakes become even higher. With Halloween approaching and the pressure of their show’s finale looming, this cozy mystery is perfect for anyone who loves a good scare mixed with a little home improvement.

BUY NOW ON AMAZON  | LISTEN FREE ON AUDIBLE

A Curse for Samhain by Dahlia Donovan

Hyde Snodgrass, a gender-fluid and autistic vampire, runs a cozy village bookstore, but when a coven leader goes missing, Hyde and their crush, Teresa, must solve a dangerous mystery. With a mix of supernatural twists, autumn vibes, and a blossoming romance, this cozy mystery is perfect for fans of magic and small-town life.

BUY NOW ON AMAZON  | LISTEN FREE ON AUDIBLE

A Very Woodsy Murder by Ellen Byron

Dee Stern escapes LA to run a rustic motel in the remote village of Foundgold, but her fresh start takes a dark turn when a guest is murdered. Between prowling bears and suspicious park rangers, Dee and her ex-husband Jeff must solve the crime before it ruins their new venture. This cozy mystery blends humor, suspense, and wilderness charm.

BUY NOW ON AMAZON  | LISTEN FREE ON AUDIBLE

Conclusion

There you’ve the list of cozy and comfy mysteries that combine supernatural sleuthing and woodsy adventure.

Also check out more fall books

15 Spooky Halloween Romance Books To Read

Fall Reading Challenge 2024 : Book Recommendations + FREE Printable

10 Best Cozy Mystery Series For Fall 2024