27 Book Club Questions For The Night She Disappeared by Lisa Jewell

This post may contain affiliate links which means if you make a purchase through my links, I will get a small commission at no extra cost to you. I only recommend the products I love and trust.

Delve into the best book club questions for The Night She Disappeared by Lisa Jewell.

I really really loved Lisa Jewell’s The Night She Disappeared. It’s one of the best thrillers with fantastic writing.

The characters were absolutely incredible. You will hate them, love them or just don’t know what to feel about them. It’s one of the best thrillers that will never bore you. Each page holds a secret or a twist, and honestly I couldn’t put it down for a minute. There were more than one plot yet I didn’t feel it confusing at all.

The setting of the story was another fascinating aspect for me. The large manor house known as Dark Place really creeped me out. And Scarlet, oh my. I think only Jewell can write a character like that. Overall, it’s the darkest thriller to read.

So if your book club has decided to read Lisa Jewell thriller book in 2024, let me help you with 27 amazing discussion questions. I promise you they are going to be the ultimate conversation starter for the members. 

The Night She Disappeared by Lisa Jewell Book Summary

The Night She Disappeared

The Night She Disappeared by Lisa Jewell is a mystery novel set in different timelines. In 2017, Tallulah, a young mom who is 19, goes on a date and doesn’t come back. Her mom, Kim, is very worried. No one knows where Tallulah is, but she was last seen going to a party at a place called Dark Place in the forest.

In 2019, Sophie, whose boyfriend works at a school nearby, finds a note in the woods. It says ‘DIG HERE’. This note is a clue about what happened to Tallulah. The novel unravels a web of family trauma, dark secrets, and the mystery surrounding an abandoned mansion, culminating in a dramatic and suspenseful conclusion.


27 The Night She Disappeared Book Club Questions

What was your initial impression of the three timelines in the book? Which one intrigued you the most, and why?

How did Lisa Jewell effectively use multiple points of view to tell the story? Did this enhance your reading experience?

Let’s start with the characters. Which character(s) did you connect with the most, and who was the most challenging to empathize with?

The story unfolds through Kim’s perspective in 2017. What are your thoughts on Kim’s determination to find her daughter, Tallulah?

How do you feel about Sophie’s character in the 2019 timeline, especially her determination to solve the mystery? Do you think her background as a mystery writer influenced her actions?

Scarlett Jacques plays a significant role in the 2017 timeline. What did you make of her character, and did your perception of her change throughout the book?

Lisa Jewell chose the title The Night She Disappeared. Do you agree with the title choice? Why or why not?

Discuss the theme of motherhood in The Night She Disappeared. How did Kim’s role as a mother impact her actions and emotions throughout the story?

The disappearance of Tallulah and Zach is a central mystery. Did you have any theories about what happened to them as you read? Were your predictions accurate?

Explore the theme of secrets in The Night She Disappeared . How do secrets affect the characters and their relationships with one another?

Sophie and Sean move into the headmaster’s cottage in 2019. How did their relationship evolve throughout the story, and what role did the cottage play in their journey?

Were you surprised by any of the plot twists in the book? Which one caught you off guard the most?

Lisa Jewell weaves elements of suspense into the narrative. How did the author build and maintain tension throughout the novel?

Discuss the significance of the ring that Sophie finds in her garden. What does it represent in the context of the story?

In the 2019 timeline, Sophie is an author of detective novels. How did her profession impact her involvement in solving the mystery?

What did you think of Lisa Jewell’s writing style and her ability to create a vivid sense of place, particularly in describing the setting of the woods and the mansion?

The Night She Disappeared explores the concept of youth and the responsibilities that come with it. How do the characters in different timelines grapple with this theme?

Kim’s unwavering belief in her daughter’s innocence is a driving force in the story. How did her character evolve as she searched for answers?

Discuss the impact of social class on the characters’ lives and choices. How did it shape their relationships and opportunities?

The story incorporates elements of romance. How did the romantic relationships in the book contribute to the overall plot?

Lisa Jewell includes elements of mystery within the narrative. Were there any clues or hints that you noticed but didn’t fully understand until later in the story?

Did you feel satisfied with the resolution of the mystery by the end of the book? Why or why not?

How did Lisa Jewell handle the pacing of the story? Did you find it well-balanced between the different timelines?

Discuss the role of friendships in the book, particularly the relationships between the college students.

Kim’s perseverance is a key theme in the book. What did you admire most about her as a character?

The book raises questions about trust and betrayal. How do the characters grapple with these themes?

Lastly, share your overall thoughts and feelings about “The Night She Disappeared. Did the book meet your expectations? Would you recommend it to others?

Books Like The Night She Disappeared

If you want to read dark and suspenseful thrillers like Lisa Jewell here are some good book suggestions. 

Wrong Place Wrong Time by Gillian McAllister

This is another propulsive thriller about a mother-child relationship that will keep you on the edge of your seat

Watching You by Lisa Jewell 

Another suspenseful page-turner by Lisa Jewell. Set in the seemingly perfect neighbourhood of Melville Heights. Secrets, obsession, and intrigue abound as residents, including the charming headmaster Tom Fitzwilliam, hide their dark side. 

Never Have I Ever by Joshilyn Jackson

If you are looking for a suspenseful read with unexpected twists, here is another good one, a lot like The Night She Disappeared. This domestic suspense thriller  starts with a a harmless drinking game that turns into a dangerous battle of dark secrets.

The Therapist by B A Paris

The Therapist by B.A. Paris is about Alice and Leo, who move into their dream home in a fancy gated community. Alice finds out a troubling secret about the person who lived there before, therapist Nina. She becomes fixated on finding the truth. This story is full of secrets and suspense, similar to The Night She Disappeared, as they both deal with hidden mysteries in perfect-looking places.

Frequently Asked Questions About The Night She Disappeared by Lisa Jewell

  • What is the plot of The Night She Disappeared?

In The Night She Disappeared, a thrilling book by bestselling author Jewell, the plot centers on Tallulah and Zach, both 19 years old, who vanish after a date night that begins at a pub and ends up at a country estate in Surrey, England. Their baby is left behind, and Tallulah’s mother, Kim, is left to look after the child, deeply troubled by their disappearance.

  • What are the central themes in The Night She Disappeared?

The book talks about grief and a parent’s strong love for their child. It shows how deeply Kim feels the loss of Tallulah and her unchanging love for her. Even in her sadness, there is a bit of hope, and Kim is determined to find out what really happened on that important night.

  • How long does it take to read The Night She Disappeared?

The Night She Disappeared is 11 hours and 56 minutes long. 


There you have it, some really great discussion question for one of my favroite thrillers of all time- The Night She Disappeared.

21 Happy Place by Emily Henry Book Club Questions & Snack Ideas

43 It Starts With Us by Colleen Hoover Book Club Questions & Snack Ideas + Free Pdf Guide

26 Remarkably Bright Creatures Book Club Questions and Snack Ideas

42 The Midnight Library Book Club Questions and Snack Ideas

The Seven Husbands of Evelyn Hugo: 25 Book club Questions

29 The Silent Patient Book Club Questions and Snack Ideas

Stephy George
Stephy George

Hi I am Stephy ! I became a bookworm in my late twenties. So I created this little corner of books online to share my love of reading with YOU! I want to help you find the best books to read so you won’t ever have to worry about your next read!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *