44 Book Club Questions For Never Lie by Freida McFadden

This post may contain affiliate links which means if you make a purchase through my links, I will get a small commission at no extra cost to you. I only recommend the products I love and trust.

Book club questions for Never Lie include delicious food ideas and fun activity suggestions to make your gathering memorable and engaging.

Freida McFadden’s suspenseful thriller, Never Lie is a gripping book club pick for 2024. If your reading group is looking for engaging discussion questions for this bestselling novel, let me help.

This blog post features 44 discussion-worthy questions for the Never Lie book club. I absolutely loved this twisted thriller with its unexpected twists, secrets, and revelations.

This psychological thriller follows newlyweds Tricia and Ethan as who find themselves trapped in a remote manor amidst a violent winter storm. When Tricia stumbles upon a hidden room containing audio transcripts from every patient of the mansion’s former owner, Dr. Adrienne Hale, she uncovers a web of lies and secrets surrounding Dr. Hale’s mysterious disappearance four years earlier.

So, I highly suggest picking up this propulsive thriller for your book group discussion this year. This book club guide that I am about to share includes food suggestions and activity ideas as well.

With its shocking twists and compelling characters, your reading group members will have plenty to discuss.

Also, don’t forget to download the printable book guide.

Never Lie Synopsis

Newlyweds Tricia and Ethan are searching for the house of their dreams.

But when they visit the remote manor that once belonged to Dr. Adrienne Hale, a renowned psychiatrist who vanished without a trace four years earlier, a violent winter storm traps them at the estate… with no chance of escape until the blizzard comes to an end.

In search of a book to keep her entertained until the snow abates, Tricia happens upon a secret room. One that contains audio transcripts from every single patient Dr. Hale has ever interviewed. As Tricia listens to the cassette tapes, she learns about the terrifying chain of events leading up to Dr. Hale’s mysterious disappearance.

Tricia plays the tapes one by one, late into the night. With each one, another shocking piece of the puzzle falls into place, and Dr. Adrienne Hale’s web of lies slowly unravels.

And then Tricia reaches the final cassette.

The one that reveals the entire horrifying truth.


45 Book Club Questions For Never Lie by Freida McFadden

How do you feel about the setting of the remote manor and the impact of the winter storm trapping the characters?

Discuss the characters of Tricia and Ethan. What are their motivations, strengths, and weaknesses?

How does the author build suspense throughout the story, particularly with the cassette tapes revealing Dr. Hale’s interviews?

Did you find the plot twists believable, or did they stretch your suspension of disbelief?

What role does the secret room play in driving the plot forward? How does it affect Tricia’s understanding of the events?

Discuss the portrayal of mental health and psychiatry in the story. How does it contribute to the overall atmosphere?

Were there any moments in the book that genuinely scared or unsettled you? If so, which ones and why?

How does the author employ the winter storm as a metaphor or symbol throughout the story?

Compare and contrast Tricia’s reactions to the cassette tapes with Ethan’s. How do they differ, and why?

Explore the concept of unreliable narration in the book. 

Discuss the pacing of the story. Did you find it engaging throughout, or were there moments where it lagged?

How does the author handle the reveal of the entire horrifying truth in the final cassette tape? Was it satisfying or anticlimactic?

Analyze the role of Dr. Hale as a character, both in her physical absence and through her recorded interviews.

What do you think motivated Dr. Hale’s actions leading up to her disappearance? Do you sympathize with her?

Discuss the significance of the title, “Never Lie,” in relation to the events of the story.

How does the book explore the theme of trust, both within relationships and in broader contexts?

If you could change one aspect of the story, what would it be and why?

How does the author balance character development with plot progression?

How does Never Lie fit within the thriller genre? What elements make it a compelling thriller?

Explore the theme of redemption as it relates to certain characters’ actions and decisions.

How does the book handle the ethical implications of listening to Dr. Hale’s confidential patient interviews?

Consider the role of secrets and revelations in driving the narrative forward. How do they impact the characters’ relationships?

Discuss the symbolism of the cassette tapes as a storytelling device. What do they represent within the context of the narrative?

How does the author use sensory details to immerse the reader in the setting of the manor and the storm?

Were there any moments of levity or humor in the book, or was it predominantly dark and suspenseful?

How does the book explore the concept of identity, particularly in relation to the secrets uncovered about Dr. Hale and her patients?

Consider the role of secondary characters in the story. Did any of them stand out to you, and why?

How does the author use ambiguity and uncertainty to keep the reader guessing throughout the story?

Reflect on your overall reading experience. What will stick with you the most about Never Lie?

What specific elements of the “haunted” house setting at the beginning of the book contributed to your sense of fear or unease? How did the author effectively build suspense in these scenes?

In what ways did “Never Lie” stand out from other books by Freida McFadden in terms of substance and depth? Can you pinpoint any moments or themes that elevated this book to a higher standard for you?

How does the author create genuine, relatable characters that enhance the overall narrative? Which characters stood out to you the most, and why?

How does the revelation of Tricia’s pregnancy add tension to the story, especially considering her reluctance to share this news with Ethan?

Discuss the significance of the manor home’s previous owner, Dr. Adrienne Hale, and the impact of her disappearance on the plot. How does her background as a psychiatrist influence the unfolding events?

Explore the character of “EJ” and his diagnosis of narcissistic personality disorder. How does his presence on the recordings contribute to the suspense and unraveling of the story?

Reflecting on the twist in the narrative, how did the unexpected revelation shape your understanding of the events leading up to Dr. Hale’s disappearance? Did it alter your perception of certain characters or plot elements?

Discuss the significance of Tricia and Ethan’s decision to stay in the house despite not having confirmation from their real estate agent. What factors influenced their choice to remain?

Did you notice any inconsistencies throughout the story, or do you feel the author managed to get everything right?

Consider Tricia’s suspicions that she and Ethan are not alone in the house. What evidence supports or contradicts her fears, and how does this contribute to the overall suspense of the story?

Explore the character development of Tricia and Ethan throughout the story. In what ways do they grow or change as they navigate the challenges they encounter?

What aspects of the story did you find most compelling, and what aspects fell short for you?

How did the use of a dual point of view, alternating between Adrienne and Tricia’s perspectives, enhance your experience of the story?

Considering the mind-blowing revelations throughout the book, what were some of the most memorable moments or revelations that stood out to you as particularly impactful or unexpected?

Reflecting on the different points of view presented in the book, how did the alternating perspectives of Tricia and Dr. Hale enhance or detract from your reading experience?

Free Downloadable Book Club Questions PDF

Download the Pdf with all 44 questions.

Snack Ideas For Never Lie Book Club Meeting

Never Lie Book Club Activity Ideas:

  • Character Interview Role-Play:
    • Assign each participant a character from the book, such as Tricia, Ethan, Dr. Adrienne Hale, or one of Dr. Hale’s patients.
    • Have each member prepare questions as if they were interviewing their assigned character.
    • Conduct a round-robin style role-play where participants ask and answer questions in character, exploring motivations, secrets, and perspectives.
  • Secret Room Scavenger Hunt:
    • Create a scavenger hunt inspired by the secret room discovered by Tricia in the book.
    • Hide clues or objects related to key plot points or themes throughout the meeting space.
    • Divide participants into teams and challenge them to solve the clues and uncover the secrets hidden within the room.
  • Truth or Lie Game:
    • Create a game inspired by the theme of truth and lies in the book.
    • Compile a list of statements related to the story, some true and some false.
    • Read each statement aloud and have participants guess whether it’s true or false.
    • After revealing the correct answer, discuss the significance of the statement and its connection to the plot or characters.

Books To Read After Never Lie

  • The Golden Couple by Greer Hendricks & Sarah Pekkanen: In “Never Lie,” where Dr. Adrienne Hale records her therapy sessions, here we meet Avery Chambers, a therapist who does things a bit differently. The Bishops, who are having some serious marriage issues after Marissa’s affair, turn to Avery for help. The way Avery works with them gets extremely intense and unpredictable.


There you have the curated list of discussion-worthy book discussion questions, food ideas and activity ideas for Never Lie book club gathering. 

More Book Club Questions

43 The Teacher by Freida McFadden Book Club Questions

51 Lessons in Chemistry Book Club Questions & Snack Ideas

29 The Silent Patient Book Club Questions and Snack Ideas

31 Tom Lake by Ann Patchett Book Club Questions & Snack Ideas

26 Remarkably Bright Creatures Book Club Questions and Snack Ideas

32 Book Club Questions For The Maid by Nita Prose

33 Book Club Questions For Wrong Place Wrong Time by Gillian McAllister

28 The Guest List Book Club Questions & Snack Ideas

Stephy George
Stephy George

Hi I am Stephy ! I became a bookworm in my late twenties. So I created this little corner of books online to share my love of reading with YOU! I want to help you find the best books to read so you won’t ever have to worry about your next read!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *